detox

Should You Do A Detox Diet?

By in , , , , , , , , ,
3 comments

The following is a guest post about detox diets by physique athlete Scott Edmed. Be sure to check out his facebook and twitter for more!

————————————————————————————————————————————————————————–

Do not fall for these detox diets!

http://www.telegraph.co.uk/health/11307754/Cleanse-your-body-with-the-alkaline-diet.html

http://www.dailymail.co.uk/health/article-3004/The-painless-detox-diet.html

Quotes such as –

The therapist told me my body had become incredibly acidic from years and years of yo-yo dieting, even though I thought I was super-healthy being vegetarian and knocking back a green smoothie with spirulina every morning’

He suggested my body was in such a toxic state from stress and overwork that there was no way it could absorb the nutrients I was consuming. He said I needed to do an alkaline cleanse.’

All of the below are extremely acid forming. To re-balance your body towards a more alkaline state you need to cut these items out of your diet; caffeine, alcohol, dairy produce, meat, sugar, wheat and gluten, processed foods’

Or

The process of drawing toxins out of your body results in classic symptoms, such as: headaches, tiredness, irritability, skin break-outs, bloating, constipation’

detoxWhenever I hear the word ‘detox’ or any program that tells you that you absolutely CAN NOT eat this type of food or another, or that you MUST buy product A, B, and C in order to lose weight, the word BS springs to my mind and my blood really boils. ‘Detox’ diets are very popular this time of year after the over indulges of Christmas, because they offer an ‘apparent quick fix’ solution. Many ‘detox’ diets try to strike fear into the individual, and fear mongering catches peoples attention which results in more money for the seller. They sell the point of ‘you’ve ruined your health over the past couple of weeks so here’s the quick fix solution to ‘rid all those bad calories.’ But in my opinion ‘detox’ diets are expensive and a complete waste of time.

At the start of January, I would much rather people took a long term attitude to healthy eating, rather than trying quick fix solutions which are not only damaging, but often don’t actually work. A lot of points ‘detox’ diets recommend cutting down on are actually not a bad idea, especially in our typical western diet. If you cut out alcohol, stop smoking and eat less junk food, you will lose weight and feel better, but that’s not because you’re eliminating toxins, you’re just putting less calories from processed foods into your body.

There are a wide variety of ‘detox’ programs, some last a day or two, others go on for several months. As seen in the article above; ‘the six-day slim down cleanse, for example, suggests a menu of raw salads with soups and smoothies to inspire those New Year weight loss plans; while for those in search of something more ambitious, the 30-day life changing cleanse.’ Protocols such as this provide a diet/structure etc for a limited time and imply you are ‘detoxed’ once it is all finished, after a week or month. They provide no education to the client helping them to alter their lifestyle to a healthy sustainable approach.

Other ‘detox’ diets involve the use of supplements or laxatives and most border on starvation diets, permitting you to drink only juice. Lowering your calories to drastically low levels, yes, results in weight loss, but is it healthy and sustainable? Real detoxification is only provided in hospitals under life threatening circumstances, usually when there are dangerous levels of drugs, alcohol, or other poisons in the body.

What About All These Toxins In Food?

detox berriesThere are some good points to take from articles like this, like drinking plenty of water, getting active and working out, and emphasizing the need of avoiding yo-yo dieting. But quotes like ‘my body was in such a toxic state from stress and overwork that there was no way it could absorb the nutrients I was consuming’ and ‘we need to rid out body of toxins so ‘detox’ diets are the only way,’ are utter BS and not backed up by any evidence. We are consuming and exposed to toxins 24/7 even in natural food, like fruit and vegetables, but they are so small they are well below any level of toxicity. Remember it is the dosage that makes it toxic!

Our body has also evolved and adapted sufficiently to deal with these toxins. Our liver, kidneys and gut effectively neutralise such substances and our lungs, skin and immune system are also great at removing toxic substances. Enzymes in our cells either break down chemicals or convert them into less harmful substances which can then be used or excreted by the body via the lymphatic system or blood. The liver in particular converts toxic substances into ones that can be removed via bile or urine. While the kidneys filter our blood and convert waste products into the urine. (2) We have been eating a wide variety of foods over millions of years and our body is always adapting and evolving, along with gut flora, to deal with new foods and chemicals.

You hear many individuals claiming that because something is not natural or present in nature it must be dangerous, even once research and testing had proved it to be safe. This is very common regarding genetically modified organisms, GMOs, and many people now are anti-GMO due to the fact they are not natural. This is an appeal to nature though; an argument in which it is proposed that “a thing is good because it is ‘natural’, or bad because it is ‘unnatural.’” Following this, this would mean something like cyanide which is found in apples to be completely safe, but we know at certain dosages cyanide is a poison. The same goes for formaldehyde which is found in tomatoes. Of course you should be skeptical and ask questions of modified and synthetic chemicals, but there is no need to avoid certain GMOs or artificial chemicals once science has proved them to be safe. Food ingredients and chemicals should be judged on the individuals circumstances and scientific evidence, not if it is natural or not. (3-4) Just because the supplements within ‘detox’ diets are sold as natural does not necessity mean they are safe nor effective.

Are Not ‘Detox’ Diets a Safe Way To Eat?

Some ‘detox’ diets can actually cause harm, due to banning food groups causing nutrient deficiencies or restricting calories so much you end up starving yourself. You hear these diet ‘gurus’ claiming that you may suffer from headaches, tiredness, irritability, skin break-outs, bloating and constipation while ‘detoxing’ but this is a sign your body is getting rid of toxins. Hold on, it is probably because you have not been consuming enough calories, vitamins, minerals and fibre! Also do not be tempted to follow a water-only ‘detox’ diet, as you won’t get sufficient nutrients necessary to live and ironically will not be able to run your natural detox system!

detox dietDetox’ diets can be expensive, pointless and possibly damaging. Simply trust your body’s complex, impressive, and entirely natural detoxifying system in order to achieve your goals and improve health; it is not rocket science. There is no need to avoid or be scared of foods that we have eaten for many years and survived off like meat and dairy, which are banned on so called ‘detox’ diets. Eat a calorie controlled balanced diet, exercise regularly, get plenty of sleep and drink enough water. If you’re serious about improving your health and weight, you need to make sustainable lifestyle changes that last beyond a few weeks or months.

Instead of trying to adopt a brand new routine and turn your life around all in one week, make a plan to implement small, sustainable lifestyle habits. For example drinking more water, getting out for a walk or workout once per week, or eating 2 pieces of fruit per day. Small steps that won’t disrupt your current routine too much will be easier to implement and stick with in the long run. Once the first step becomes a habit, start a second one. So look to consume enough nutrients (protein, carbs, fats) from a wide variety of minimally processed nutrient dense foods and follow a properly designed training programme!

A healthy lifestyle isn’t built all in one day, it’s a series of small changes built on top of one another for a strong, solid foundation.

Further Reading –

http://www.sciencebasedmedicine.org/detox-what-they-dont-want-you-to-know/

http://www.theguardian.com/lifeandstyle/2014/dec/05/detox-myth-health-diet-science-ignorance

http://www.dailymail.co.uk/health/article-2897613/Alkaline-diet-Detox-fans-claim-avoiding-acid-food-slows-ageing-experts-say-dangerously-wrong.html

Follow me over on Twitter & Facebook for more fitness tips, and let us know what your macro intake is down in the comments section below.

For more info from Colin sign up for his free email newsletter that sends daily tips, advice and motivation right to your email!

References

1. http://www.innerbody.com/image_digeov/card10-new2.html

2. http://www.innerbody.com/image_urinov/dige05-new.html

3. Wagner W1, Kronberger NSeifert F. Collective symbolic coping with new technology: Knowledge, images and public discourse. Br J Soc Psychol. 2002 Sep;41(Pt 3):323-43.

4. Slovic P. Perception of risk. Science. 1987 Apr 17;236(4799):280-5.

3 comments on “Should You Do A Detox Diet?”

  1. Reply

    Have to disagree with any blanket statement like ‘Detoxes don’t work’ or ‘Detoxes work’. First, every body is different and has different strengths and failings and second, studies always compare detoxers to people eating healthy, organic diets. But out in the real world, very, very few people eat a healthy organic diet.

    Let’s apply a little common sense… It may be true that the body can successfully clean out toxins – but obviously it should have an easier time of it during a period where you’re not adding in more toxins. Second, it all depends on what you ingest on the detox – if it’s a healthy blend of protein and fats with at least enough carbs to get you through the day, there’s no reason to infer it’s not healthy.

    Teri & I are preparing to try a 10-day program, billed as a cleanse, not a detox. Why? To give our systems a chance to clear out any backlog of waste products, to give our insulin receptors a chance to recover somewhat, and to give our system a mini-restart. We already have our nutrition on point and live a healthy lifestyle, so this could be considered a quick tune-up. Is it necessary in our case? Probably not. But if it does give us that little bit more of an edge and makes us even slightly more healthy and optimal, we’d be foolish NOT to try it.

      • colindewaaytraining
      • February 12, 2015
      Reply

      I don’t want to speak for Scott (and I’ve alerted him to this comment) but I believe you are missing the point of this article Doug. The main point I personally took from it was that you shouldn’t look to some sort of a detox or cleanse over making more sustainable lasting changes to a healthier life. Most of the time people are looking for a quick fix, and not something that will make a real difference.

      Personally I don’t see the point of a cleanse if you are already living a healthy lifestyle, but I wouldn’t stop anyone such as yourself from trying it if they want. Unless you were a client of mine who wanted to do it and have severe caloric restrictions from it, that is. 🙂

      • Scott Edmed
      • February 12, 2015
      Reply

      Totally agree Colin, the problem is people look to a detox diet for a sustainable diet and want results fast. Anyone will suffer to sustain most FAD diets, that’s the major problem with them.

      The problem is most people that follow detox diets do not get adequate protein, carbs or fats because all they are drinking is fruit and veg. Therefore there diet is massively lacking in nutrients. This can have massive implications on an individual who trains.

      I also question you quote ‘a period where you’re not adding in extra toxins.’ Are you aware we are exposed to toxins each and every day in the air we breath?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *